A10-Down with metal
By Jacob Schwartzstein - May 24, 2006
The ping of these aluminum bats is killing me.
My junior year of high school, four years ago, the conference my school was in switched from aluminum bats to wood bats after a horrific scene the previous year when a friend of mine almost died after being hit in the head with a line drive while he was pitching. Because attending the A10 tourney today is the first time in over four years that I've been to a game where aluminum bats are used, I had forgotten how awful they are.
The sound of a wood bat hitting a ball is music to my ears; the sound of a metal bat hitting a ball is Ashlee Simpson to my ears.
It's time for the NCAA to switch to wood bats. In addition to the injury and sound factor, wood bats would allow people to truly see how good a hitter is. Just like a good three-point shooter in college may not be very good from NBA three-point range, a good power hitter in college, or just any kind of hitter in general, may not be as good as we think either. Conversely, college pitchers are probably better than their stats show. I have a lot more respect for guys like Steve Holmes, No. 1 seeded Rhode Island's star pitcher and the A-10 pitcher of the year, knowing that his ridiculous 1.14 ERA actually is inflated simply because his opposition uses metal bats.
Posted by Jacob Schwartzstein at 03:01 PM on May 24, 2006
Comments (2)
Comments
What happened to the live streaming at the A10 games?
Comment by RJ - May 24, 2006 03:39 PM
What a dead-on, relevant post. It is absolutely absurd that division 1 college level players still use aluminum bats. On one hand, it is impossible to logically analyze the skills of a D-1 player whose natural talents are enhanced by the trampoline response of metal bats. These bats are the equipment equivalent of steroids. Why isn't the wood vs. metal controversy a national hot topic issue like steroids are in MLB? Also, metal bats are simply unnatural. The game was created to be played using wood bats. Pros use wood bats. Why would college players - players good enough to be considering pro careers - be using these metal bats? And finally - and most importantly - aluminum bats are dangerous. They unneccessarily risk lives; the lives of young players and college level athletes alike. Not to mention, as Jake pointed out, the ping really is unpleasant. With all the negatives, at the end of the day...what's the point?
Comment by Tom Lakin - May 25, 2006 12:01 AM